He emphasizes the three years of starvation and social boycott Abu Talib endured alongside the early Muslims, suggesting this level of sacrifice for the Messenger of God is inconsistent with being a "non-believer". Review of the Content Style Scholarly yet Emotional:

In conclusion, Iman-e-Abu Talib by Dr. Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri is a bold scholarly endeavor that revisits a contentious chapter of Islamic history. Through rigorous citation and theological reasoning, Dr. Qadri challenges the majority opinion within his own broader Sunni tradition to present a case for Abu Talib’s salvation. The "fixed" digital editions of the book serve as vital tools for researchers and believers, preserving the nuances of his argument. Whether one agrees with his conclusions or not, the book stands as a testament to the dynamism of Islamic scholarship, proving that history remains a living subject, open to re-evaluation and debate.

: It contains comprehensive research and analysis of various Ahadith to support its theological arguments.

Critics often cite the verse: "Nor will the Jews or Christians be pleased with you unless you follow their creed..." Dr. Qadri explains that classical exegetes (Tafsir al-Razi, Tafsir al-Qurtubi) differentiate between a "protecting non-believer" (Kafir Dhimmi) and a "supportive relative." The book argues that Abu Talib fits the latter.